Von Krummp Publishing All articles
Reading Culture

Prosecco, Peppermint Tea and Plot Holes: A Very British Book Group Refreshment Index

Priya Deshmukh
Prosecco, Peppermint Tea and Plot Holes: A Very British Book Group Refreshment Index

Photo: Jon Sullivan, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Every book group claims to be about books. A modest amount of fieldwork — conducted mostly in kitchens, conservatories and one memorable garden shed in Leicestershire — suggests otherwise. The refreshments come first; the discussion follows them the way a Labrador follows a biscuit tin. Change the drink and you change the meeting entirely. This is not cynicism. It is method.

The index

Picture a scale of one to ten, where one is a glass of tap water and ten is a second bottle nobody admits to opening. Where a group sits on that scale predicts, with unnerving accuracy, how the evening will go. Below is the taxonomy, offered in the spirit of public service and with no expectation of being thanked.

The Prosecco Chapter

Index rating: 8, rising to 9 after the second bottle.

The Prosecco group is the most fun and the least well read. Three members finished the book; two read the blurb and the ending; one is holding a copy borrowed from a sister-in-law and has been holding it, unopened, for eleven weeks. Nobody minds, because by the time the cork goes the discussion has stopped being about the book and become about everything else — a colleague's wedding, a school catchment area, whether anyone actually likes anchovies.

Faintly sparkling drinks generate faintly sparkling criticism. Nothing is ever disliked at a Prosecco meeting; things are “interesting” and “quite brave”. The book will be chosen for next month by whoever is nearest the bottle, and it will be a hardback nobody finishes.

The Biscuit Parliament

Index rating: 4, with a chocolate escalator.

The most British of all the models. Tea in mugs, a plate of assorted biscuits arranged with genuine care, and a discussion that runs precisely to time. This group does read the book. It also disagrees about it in an extremely polite fashion, in which the phrase “I take your point, but” is deployed as a weapon of moderate mass destruction. The biscuit hierarchy governs the evening: the good ones go first, the custard creams are left to the end, and whoever brings the plain digestives is quietly noted.

The Herbal Tea Circle

Index rating: 1.5.

Peppermint. Chamomile. A jug of water with a slice of lemon in it, and the lemon is not doing much. The Herbal Tea Circle approaches the book as a text, with notes, and the notes have subheadings. Somebody has printed a review. Somebody else has brought the author's earlier work “for context”. The meeting feels like a seminar and ends like one, with everyone agreeing warmly and leaving slightly tired.

And yet: they finished the book, all of them, and they will remember it in a year's time. There is a lesson in that, which nobody wants to hear.

The Pub-Adjacent Group

Index rating: 6, plus crisps.

Meets upstairs in a pub, which resolves the hosting question and creates a new one: whether a plate of chips counts as hospitality. It does. This group has the best arguments, because the setting permits a raised voice, and the worst attendance, because January. Books are chosen by whoever has been to a bookshop most recently.

The Overcaterer

Index rating: 3, but with a cheese board.

One host, one enormous spread, one book nobody has read because the host was too busy baking. The Overcaterer is not running a reading group; they are running a supper club with a literary alibi, and honestly, fair enough. The discussion peaks during the second helping of something warm.

The host's job description

Nobody tells you what hosting actually involves. Officially: choose the book, provide the venue, keep the conversation moving. In practice: chill the wine, buy two kinds of milk, remember that one member is dairy-free and another is not speaking to a third, arrange seating so the two most talkative members are separated by a lamp, and produce something to eat that does not require cutlery.

The host also carries the burden of the opening question. Too broad and the evening collapses into anecdote; too pointed and it becomes an exam. The great hosts ask something unanswerable and slightly nosy — “who would you least like to be stuck in a lift with, and why is it the husband?” — and then get out of the way.

So is the wine the reason anyone joins?

Not the reason. The permission. The drink sets the volume, and the volume sets the honesty. A group that drinks nothing much will tell you what it thinks of the book. A group that drinks a great deal will tell you what it thinks of everything, which is a different and often better evening, though a worse reading group.

The ideal, as ever, sits in the middle: a group with a book it has mostly read, a host with a decent plate of something, and enough on the table to make the disagreement enjoyable. Call it a five on the index. Add crisps.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Spare-Room Shelf: Britain’s Most Honest Bookcase

The Spare-Room Shelf: Britain’s Most Honest Bookcase

The Swollen Spine Files: A Bath-Time Reading Risk Assessment for the Brave British Bookworm

The Swollen Spine Files: A Bath-Time Reading Risk Assessment for the Brave British Bookworm

What Britain Leaves Between the Pages: An Unauthorised Bookmark Bestiary

What Britain Leaves Between the Pages: An Unauthorised Bookmark Bestiary