Von Krummp Publishing All articles
Reading Culture

Open at Ninety-Nine: What One Arbitrary Page Tells You About a Novel, and About Yourself

Von Krummp Publishing
Open at Ninety-Nine: What One Arbitrary Page Tells You About a Novel, and About Yourself

Photo: hands opening novel to page in bookshop browsing paperback shelves, via img.freepik.com

There is a piece of writing advice that has been passed around for so long that nobody can remember quite where it came from, in the way that nobody can remember who first said you should never trust a thin chef. The advice goes like this: open a novel at page 99 and read it. If the writing holds up, the book is worth your time. If it doesn’t, put it down.

The rule is usually credited to Ford Madox Ford, which is the literary equivalent of a rumour becoming true because the accused is dead and cannot object. Whether or not he said it, it has the unmistakable ring of something invented by a man who wanted an excuse to be rude about other people’s novels in public.

Which is, let’s be honest, most of literary criticism.

The Appeal of a Rule With a Number On It

What makes the page 99 test so seductive is that it feels scientific. It has a number in it. It offers a verdict in ninety seconds. Compare that with the traditional method — reading three hundred pages and then being unable to decide whether you liked it — and you can see the attraction.

It is also, structurally, rather clever. Page 99 of a typical novel lands somewhere in the second third, past the setup, before the ending has begun arranging itself. The honeymoon of chapter one is over. The scaffolding is up. If the author has style, it should be visible. If the author is only good at openings, this is where you catch them.

The Experiment

So on a wet Tuesday in a bookshop in Norwich, with permission and a cup of tea, I did it properly. Twelve novels off the shelf — a Booker-ish literary hardback, two crime novels, a family saga, a comic novel, a translated prize-winner, a historical doorstopper, and an assortment of paperbacks chosen for looking well-thumbed. Page 99 of each, read cold, no covers, no blurbs, no author names visible to the person doing the reading.

Three observations emerged almost immediately.

First: page 99 is rarely a beginning. Almost none of the twelve started a chapter there. Most landed mid-conversation, or mid-sentence, or on a page of dialogue with no attribution in sight. Judging a novel from this is not unlike judging a marriage by walking into the kitchen halfway through an argument.

Second: dialogue dominates. Six of the twelve pages were predominantly speech. Two were almost entirely white space. One was a description of a hillside so beautifully over-written that the reader laughed out loud, which was the only genuinely decisive verdict of the afternoon.

Third: the good pages were good in ways unrelated to plot. What stood out was rhythm — whether the sentences had a pulse you could hear. A crime novel with an unremarkable story had a page 99 that read like a well-tuned engine. A prize-winning literary novel, much admired, had a page 99 so airless that two readers independently described it as “tiring”.

The Bookseller’s Objection

“It’s a parlour game,” said the bookseller, reshelving the evidence. “A good one. But it’s a game. Page 99 of a book you’ll love and page 99 of a book you’ll hate can sound identical out of context. Context is the entire point of a novel. That’s what a novel is for.”

She has a point that the rule cannot answer. A novel is not a collection of equally weighted pages. It is a structure, and structures have dull load-bearing sections, the literary equivalent of the bit behind the plasterboard.

The Novelist’s Objection

Then there is the fatal technical flaw, which nobody mentions because it is unglamorous: page 99 is an accident of pagination. Change the trim size, the font, the leading, the paper stock, or simply the length of the preface, and page 99 becomes a completely different piece of text. Set the same novel in a different edition and the test samples an entirely different paragraph.

Which means the page 99 test is not measuring the author at all. It is measuring the production department.

The novelist I asked about this was delighted. “So you’re not judging my prose,” she said. “You’re judging my typesetter’s margins. I’ve been blamed for a lot of things in my career. This is the first time I’ve been blamed for my trim size.”

Where the Test Actually Works

Strip away the mystique and something modest survives. The test does two things rather well.

It measures sentence-level control. Can this writer sustain a paragraph without you looking away? That is not nothing. It is, in fact, quite a lot.

It measures voice. A page read cold, with no cover and no blurb, tells you whether you would recognise this writer again in the dark. That is rarer and more valuable than plot.

What it cannot measure is whether the book is any good, because “good” in a novel depends on the arrangement of the whole. A single page is a still from a film. You can tell if the lighting is competent. You cannot tell if the film works.

The Honest Verdict

So: use it, but use it as a thermometer, not a verdict. Open at page 99 in a shop, read it, and ask one question only — do I want to hear this voice for three hundred more pages? If the answer is no, put it back. If the answer is yes, buy it.

And if the answer is “I’d like to, but the leading is a bit mean”, then you have fallen into a different argument entirely, and there is a whole other article about that.

The deeper lesson, though, is uncomfortable. Of the twelve novels tested, the two readers involved disagreed on nine. Nine. The page 99 test does not reveal the quality of a book. It reveals, with almost insulting clarity, the taste of the person holding it — and that person has been carrying prejudices around all afternoon like a bag of shopping.

Ford Madox Ford, wherever he is, is probably delighted.

All Articles

Related Articles

Prosecco, Peppermint Tea and Plot Holes: A Very British Book Group Refreshment Index

Prosecco, Peppermint Tea and Plot Holes: A Very British Book Group Refreshment Index

The Spare-Room Shelf: Britain’s Most Honest Bookcase

The Spare-Room Shelf: Britain’s Most Honest Bookcase

The Swollen Spine Files: A Bath-Time Reading Risk Assessment for the Brave British Bookworm

The Swollen Spine Files: A Bath-Time Reading Risk Assessment for the Brave British Bookworm